Castle Rock Entertainment, Inc. v. Carol Publishing Group Inc. · US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit · 1998
Does the trivia book infringe?
Short answer: Yes: it took from the show.
The facts. A fan wrote a trivia book of 643 questions about Seinfeld, from character names to tiny plot details. The show's owner sued. The author said trivia is just facts, and that this was a harmless fan tribute.
The ruling. Castle Rock v. Carol Publishing (1998): The court held the book infringed, because the 'facts' were invented by the show's writers, and the book was not a fair use.
The book was called The Seinfeld Aptitude Test. The publisher was ordered to destroy its unsold copies. The court noted the quiz did nothing to transform the show.
Be the judge: play today's five casesFor fun, not legal advice.